Anthypophora (an’-thi-po’-phor-a): A figure of reasoning in which one asks and then immediately answers one’s own questions (or raises and then settles imaginary objections). Reasoning aloud. Anthypophora sometimes takes the form of asking the audience or one’s adversary what can be said on a matter, and thus can involve both anacoenosis and apostrophe.
Are there nine ways to skin a cat? The answer is no. The are no ways to skin a cat, unless, of course, you’re some kind of psychopath. It would be better to say “There are nine ways to skin a rabbit.” I don’t know what they are. I can only think of two ways. But, two may be enough to capture the meaning of the “skinning trope.” All it says, is that there are more ways than one way to do something. Really, “nine ways” summons overstatement and registers as hyperbole—a figure of exaggeration.
I believe the “nine ways” trope should be prohibited. I don’t want to think about cats being skinned. I own a big fluffy cat named Lucy, and I would kill anybody who would try to skin her. Or maybe, I would simply report them to the police and the SPCA and call it a day, rescuing my cat from the clutches of a dark-hearted fiend, who would skin my cat just to make a point.
Is it surprising that antiquated sayings persist? No. People haven’t changed in the thousands of years that they’ve inhabited the world. For example, having a “tiger by the tail,” can probably be traced back to cave people trying to move a saber-toothed tiger out of a cave so they could move in. Today, the saying means something about holding onto a vexing idea or person who emotionally flings you around, is so unruly with their emotions that holding onto the relationship is like holding a tiger by the tail to keep it from biting you: a very dangerous strategy that often results in letting go and running away. If you’re chased anyway, you’re screwed. So, what can you do? I would get a lawyer and get a restraining order.
So, what have we accomplished here? Nothing much.