Antithesis


Antithesis (an-tith’-e-sis): Juxtaposition of contrasting words or ideas (often, although not always, in parallel structure).


Black-white. Yes-no. Good-bad. Broken-fixed. Big-small. Everything in the universe has an opposite that can comport with it only as an opposite, reflecting differences that divide and unite us, or things; concepts seen or voiced from opposing points of view.

Something can’t be and not be its opposite at the same time under the same circumstances. That’s Aristotle’s primary axiom. It is where arguments often begin, and surely where conflict begins if parties seek to establish their difference as the ascendant point of view. Although the difference is the “either/or” of contradictories, there can be degrees of difference. I say “It’s too warm.” You say, “It’s not warm enough.” If we’re sane, we’ll grudgingly compromise with the thermostat. If we’re not so sane, we’ll stick to our guns and do things like opening windows, wrestling over the thermostat, or marking this as the last straw in a string of petty disagreements and a trigger to goodbye: “We don’t see eye to eye on anything. Goodbye asshole.” We forget that on many issues we can both be wrong, if not tight.

We like people who are like us. Maybe we shouldn’t limit our horizons, but we do. It keeps us from feeling alone. But whatever we share can be exploited to prompt solidarity to evil ends, but there are also good ends that can only be achieved by groups. It’s as if there’s nothing immune from evil’s rot or good’s confectionary triumph over evil. Fire must be fought with fire from time to time, for humanity’s sake. It’s the dialectical play of opposites that to a large extent constructs the human condition from our otherness, our uniqueness, our similarities, and the acceptance and rejection demanded of choice-making beings, using and misusing symbols (K. Burke) as we go our glorious/inglorious ways: noble and ignoble, from time to time, from place to place: locked in circumstances that we and others find or construct to find and construct the meanings of our lives.

Many of use prefer to live in the middle between extremes, avoiding conflict and constructing seemingly placid relationships. However, under the Plaster Saint syndrome, these kinds of relationships explode— compromise is inherently unsatisfying, and usually cracks and collapses into the rubble of The End.

Some say “it is better to have loved and lost, than to never have loved at all.” (Tennyson). I think that “losing” is intrinsic to loving. Only a psychopath could not love at all. Love never runs smoothly—relationships are inherently vexed. It isn’t a question whether pain accompanies love, it is question of how intense, how ubiquitous, how enduring, how much self-sacrifice it engenders. If pain is constant or frequent, maybe there just isn’t’t enough common ground, and one may rightfully flee. In this context constant self-sacrifice may ironically become the chief site of “who you are.”

Anyway, contraries are what make us human—make us choice -making beings. Our ability to perceive opposites, clinging to one pole while rejecting the other, and at some time rejecting one for the other again wraps our lives in the magical cloak of uncertainty making persuasion the pathway to belief: a the contingent settling of vexation, the keynote of human being—a participle modifying life.

Bottom Line

I’m no logician. I’m sucked in by, and construct, fallacies like everybody else. imperfection is my key characteristic. I’ll probably revise this at some point. For now, it’s the best I can do. At least I tried. It’s either worth reading or not. That’s a contradictory.

Leave a Reply